Abstract
Grisel syndrome is a condition of uncertain etiology characterized by a non-traumatic atlantoaxial subluxation following an infection in the head and neck region. Although first described in 1830, the exact pathophysiology of Grisel syndrome remains unclear. We present a case of atlantoaxial subluxation after acute lymphadenitis diagnosed with a dynamic computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). A previously healthy 9-year-old male patient presented with torticollis of sudden onset. Dynamic CT and MR imaging showed rotary atlantoaxial subluxation and inflammation surrounding the cervical spinal ligaments. A follow-up MRI of the cervical spine, taken 3 weeks after the onset of symptoms, showed a complete resolution of subluxation and inflammation surrounding the cervical spinal ligaments. In this case report, we support the hypothesis that an inflammation-induced laxity of the cervical ligaments is the pathologic key to Grisel syndrome using radiologic findings.
-
Keywords: Lymhadenitis, Atlantoaxial joint, Torticollis
INTRODUCTION
Grisel syndrome is a condition of uncertain etiology characterized by a non-traumatic rotary atlantoaxial subluxation associated with a head and neck infection. Children are most frequently affected following an episode of infection in the head and neck region [
1]. The presenting symptom other than the history of an infection is a persisting torticollis with neck stiffness and/or pain upon neck movement.
There are different proposed explanations for the pathogenesis, and Grisel himself first suggested that the subluxation developed secondary to muscle spasm [
2]. Watson-Jones and Roberts [
3] suggested hyperemia of the blood supply of bone, following an infections or surgical trauma, leads to decalcification of the anterior arch of the atlas, and the decalcification, in turn, induces laxity of the anterior transverse ligament between the atlas and the axis. Wittek [
4] further hypothesized that the subluxation is allowed by the distension of the ligaments with maintenance of the bony-ligamentous attachment. A two-hit hypothesis [
5] proposed that non-traumatic subluxation requires pre-existing cervical ligamentous laxity, common among children, and inflammatory mediators carried to the cervical muscles by the pharyngovertebral plexus and these conditions induced cervical spasm and subsequent atlantoaxial subluxation.
We describe a case of Grisel syndrome in which sequential computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans were obtained. These imaging studies support the two-hit hypothesis of the etiology behind Grisel syndrome.
CASE REPORT
A 9-year-old male child was referred for evaluation of torticollis, and his recent medical history was significant for an episode of acute lymphadenitis on the neck 20 days ago, which was treated with intravenous antibiotics (ceftriaxone; Ceftriaxone, 2 g per day) and antiphlogistic therapy (diclofenac; Difexin, 45 mg per day) for 9 days. Otherwise, the parents reported no history of trauma or pre-existing health condition. He presented with torticollis of sudden onset 20 days after acute lymphadenitis of the neck.
Physical examination revealed limited cervical range of motion. His head was rotated to the right and tilted to the left. Nuchal spasm was present on the left side. No neurological impairment was observed.
Contrast CT of the neck was performed with side-to-side neck rotation, which revealed a significant rotary subluxation of C1 on C2 and an increased anterior atlantodental interval (
Fig. 1), consistent with a Fielding type 2 rotatory subluxation. Contrast MRI of the neck revealed no neural involvement but demonstrated enhancement of the occipital condyle, C1 superior articular process, C1/C2 facet joint and atlantoaxial interval, indicating inflammation of those structures (
Figs. 2,
3). A Philadelphia neck brace was applied initially, and the patient was treated with halter traction for 14 days and antiphlogistic (morniflumate; Morniflu, 350 mg per day) therapy for 7 days. The torticollis resolved after three weeks, and the patient had complete return of cervical ranges of motion. Follow-up with dynamic CT and MRI scans taken 21 days from onset of the torticollis revealed complete resolution of the inflammation. He was discharged home with the Philadelphia neck brace and had no lasting limitation or deficits.
DISCUSSION
Grisel syndrome primarily affects the pediatric population, with 68% of cases occurring in patients under the age of 12 years [
6] and 90% under the age of 21 [
7]. The syndrome has been reported to be associated with a head and neck surgical operation most commonly followed by upper respiratory infection as the second most common [
7].
Patients with Grisel syndrome typically present with a fixed torticollis, possible history of fever, and other signs and symptoms of previous infection. On physical examination, nuchal muscle spasm is commonly observed. CT of the neck is the gold standard for diagnosis and further workup.
Several theories have been proposed to explain the pathogenesis of this inflammatory subluxation, but its etiology and exact pathogenesis continues to be debated. However, these hypotheses cannot account for the increased incidence of Grisel syndrome in children and a mechanism for the spread of infection or inflammatory mediators.
Battiata and Pazos [
5] proposed the two-hit hypothesis that the first "hit" is a pre-existing cervical ligamentous laxity seen in the pediatric population at baseline. The normal adult atlas-dens interval ranges from 2.5 to 3 mm, where as in children, this same interval ranges up to 4.5 mm. This pre-existing laxity of the stabilizing soft tissues of C1 and C2 predisposes children for a potential subluxation event-the first "hit". The second "hit" is the cervical muscle spasm caused by the inflammatory mediators transported by the pharyngovertebral plexus.
A study by Parke et al. [
8] provides an anatomic explanation for the second component of the two-hit hypothesis by demonstrating the role of pharyngovertebral veins play between the retropharyngeal space and atlantoaxial space. These veins drain the lymphatics of retropharyngeal space. In the presence of a head or neck infection, the pharyngovertebral veins would transport the inflammatory mediators from the pharynx to the soft tissues surrounding C1-C2 segment.
In a case report, Galer et al. [
9] presented a 3-year-old girl with torticollis following an episode of tonsillitis and through a CT study, revealed low density fluid collection in the prevertebral space superior and posterior to the left palatine tonsil in addition to the C1-C2 atlantoaxial subluxation. In that study, the one-month follow-up CT scan revealed a normal alignment of the cervical vertebrae and resolution of the fluid collection.
Our case with MRI studies showed similar support for the inflammatory mediators being the cause of muscle spasm. Our case supports the hypothesis that inflammation-induced laxity of cervical ligament is the pathologic key to Grisel syndrome found in MRI findings. The enhancement of tissues surrounding cervical spine on the initial MRI and its resolution on the follow-up MRI study corresponded with the clinical presentation and resolution of torticollis in the patient.
Early detection of atlantoaxial subluxation and adequate antibiotics and antiphlogistic therapy can lead to early recovery. Deichmueller and Welkoborsky [
10] reported that four of 12 patients who starting of therapy were delayed with Grisel syndrome had persisted torticollis despite adequate conservative treatment, and those patients required a delayed external fixation. Grisel syndrome should be taken into consideration for a pediatric patient who presents with acute torticollis after an episode of infection or head and neck surgery.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This research was supported by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology (NRF-2010-0005450).
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
REFERENCES
- 1. Sullivan AW. Subluxation of the atlanto-axial joint, sequel to inflammatory processes of the neck. J Pediatr 1949;35:451-464.
- 2. Wetzel FT, La Rocca H. Grisel's syndrome. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1989;240:141-152.
- 3. Watson-Jones R, Roberts PE. Calcification, decalcification, and ossification. Br J Surg 1934;21:461-499.
- 4. Wittek A. Ein fall von distensionluxation im atlantoepistropheal gelenke. Munch Med Wochenschr 1908;55:1936-1939.
- 5. Battiata AP, Pazos G. Grisel's syndrome: the two-hit hypothesis-a case report and literature review. Ear Nose Throat J 2004;83:553-555.
- 6. Gourin CG, Kaper B, Abdu WA, Donegan JO. Nontraumatic atlanto-axial subluxation after retropharyngeal cellulitis: Grisel's syndrome. Am J Otolaryngol 2002;23:60-65.
- 7. Wilson BC, Jarvis BL, Haydon RC 3rd. Nontraumatic subluxation of the atlantoaxial joint: Grisel's syndrome. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1987;96:705-708.
- 8. Parke WW, Rothman RH, Brown MD. The pharyngovertebral veins: an anatomical rationale for Grisel's syndrome. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1984;66:568-574.
- 9. Galer C, Holbrook E, Treves J, Leopold D. Grisel's syndrome: a case report and review of the literature. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 2005;69:1689-1692.
- 10. Deichmueller CM, Welkoborsky HJ. Grisel's syndrome: a rare complication following "small" operations and infections in the ENT region. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2010;267:1467-1473.
Fig. 1(A) This dynamic computed tomography (CT) study demonstrates the rotary atlantoaxial subluxation with an anterior displacement of atlas relative to axis, corresponding to a Fielding type 2 subluxation. Rotation of the neck reveals asymmetric movement of the odontoid process. (B) Rotated to left side. (C) Rotated to right side. (D) The three-week follow-up CT scan shows complete resolution of atlantoaxial subluxation.
Fig. 2The initial T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study shows enhancement of atlantodental interval (A) and superior articular facet of axis (B). Repeated MRI, 16 days later, shows disappearance of signal change in atlanto-dental joint (C) and superior facet articulation of axis (D).
Fig. 3(A) The initial sagittal T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging view shows enhancement of tissue surrounding the dens. (B) Repeat study shows resolution of the same.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
- Torticollis in a child with Grisel syndrome: A case report and review of the literature
Bishal Budha, Sujan Paudel, Prajjwol Luitel, Bishweshwar Joshi, Arun Upreti, Nischal Ghimire
International Journal of Surgery Case Reports.2025; 127: 110817. CrossRef - Diagnostic Approach and Treatment Options for Pediatric Cases of Grisel’s Syndrome Post Otolaryngology Procedure: A Systematic Review
Omair H Al-Hussain, Ghadah Al-Hussain
Cureus.2024;[Epub] CrossRef - A Case Report of Grisel’s Syndrome Complicating the Postoperative Course of Craniotomy for a Massive Cystic Brain Lesion
Takara R Newsome-Cuby, Kwadwo Darko, Peace Odiase, Sean O'Leary, Charles Marchese, Michael J Valentine, Benjamin Pautler, Usama AlDallal, Mohamed Ismail, Fakhar Hayat
Cureus.2024;[Epub] CrossRef - A Case of Grisel’s Syndrome After Tonsillectomy and Adenoidectomy
Sea Eun Yi, Yoo-Sam Chung
Korean Journal of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery.2022; 65(9): 533. CrossRef - Magnetic Resonance Imaging as the Primary Imaging Modality in Children Presenting with Inflammatory Nontraumatic Atlantoaxial Rotatory Subluxation
Katharina J. Wenger, Elke Hattingen, Luciana Porto
Children.2021; 8(5): 329. CrossRef - Atlantoaxial Rotatory Subluxation: A Rare Complication of Craniofacial Surgery
Viren Patel, Robin Yang, Sameer Shakir, Mari Groves, Scott P. Bartlett
Journal of Craniofacial Surgery.2020; 31(1): 166. CrossRef - Occipital condyle syndrome in a case of rotatory atlantoaxial subluxation (type II) with craniovertebral junction tuberculosis: Should we operate on “active tuberculosis?”
Ashutosh Kumar, Suyash Singh, Priyadarshi Dikshit, KuntalKanti Das, ArunKumar Srivastava
Journal of Craniovertebral Junction and Spine.2020; 11(2): 143. CrossRef - Grisel’s Syndrome in Children: Two Case Reports and Systematic Review of the Literature
Nicole Pini, Martina Ceccoli, Patrizia Bergonzini, Lorenzo Iughetti, Piero Pavone
Case Reports in Pediatrics.2020; 2020: 1. CrossRef - Atlantoaxial subluxation in the pediatric patient: Case series and literature review
Mazzola Catherine A, Christie Catherine, Snee Isabel A, Iqbal Hamail
Journal of Neuroscience and Neurological Disorders.2020; 4(2): 069. CrossRef - Grisel’s syndrome associated with tonsillitis
Mahmoud Khodabandeh, Saeed Shakiba, Soroosh Alizadeh, Hamid Eshaghi
IDCases.2019; 15: e00470. CrossRef - Grisel Syndrome in Pediatric Age: A Single-Center Italian Experience and Review of the Literature
Pasquale Anania, Piero Pavone, Mattia Pacetti, Monica Truffelli, Marco Pavanello, Marcello Ravegnani, Alessandro Consales, Armando Cama, Gianluca Piatelli
World Neurosurgery.2019; 125: 374. CrossRef - Interventional magnetic resonance imaging as a diagnostic and therapeutic method in treating acute pediatric atlantoaxial rotatory subluxation
Juuli Hannonen, Marja Perhomaa, Niina Salokorpi, Willy Serlo, Roberto Sequeiros, Jaakko Sinikumpu
Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine.2019;[Epub] CrossRef - Craniovertebral Junction Abnormalities in Surgical Patients With Congenital Muscular Torticollis
Ah-Reum Ahn, Ueon Woo Rah, Ji-Eun Woo, Sunghoon Park, Sanghyun Kim, Shin-Young Yim
Journal of Craniofacial Surgery.2018; 29(3): e327. CrossRef - A Case of Grisel Syndrome Showing No Underlying Laxity of the Atlanto-axial Joint
Ah-Reum Ahn, Yul-Hyun Park, Eun Ji Park, Shin-Young Yim
Annals of Rehabilitation Medicine.2017; 41(3): 511. CrossRef - Torticollis in Children
Anne Filleron, Mohamed L’Kaissi, Jérôme Cottalorda, Eric Jeziorski, Michel Rodière, Olivier Prodhomme, Tu Anh Tran
Clinical Pediatrics.2016; 55(5): 459. CrossRef - Akuter Schiefhals oder Grisel-Syndrom
B. Schulze, L. Beyer
Manuelle Medizin.2016; 54(4): 251. CrossRef - Case Report of Atlantoaxial Rotatory Fixation after Cochlear Implantation
Takahiro Nakashima, Keiji Matsuda, Takumi Okuda, Tetsuya Tono, Minoru Takaki, Tamon Hayashi, Yutaka Hanamure
Case Reports in Otolaryngology.2016; 2016: 1. CrossRef - Tortícolis muscular congénito
P. Peyrou, Y. Lefèvre
EMC - Aparato Locomotor.2015; 48(2): 1. CrossRef - Cervical Traction for the Treatment of Spinal Injury and Deformity
Joanne H. Wang, Alan H. Daniels, Mark A. Palumbo, Craig P. Eberson
JBJS Reviews.2014;[Epub] CrossRef
